Middletown, NY
Best Restaurants in Middletown, NY
175 venues · showing 25–48 · updated October 2026
- ClosedCaputo's Pizzeria0check-ins
- ClosedCarbonella0check-ins
- ClosedCarlo’s Cucina Italiana0check-ins
- ClosedCarlos' Pizzeria and Bar0check-ins
- ClosedCarmelas Pizza0check-ins
- ClosedCharlie Brown's0check-ins
- ClosedChavos Pizza0check-ins
- ClosedChili's Grill & Bar0check-ins
- ClosedChina 10check-ins
- ClosedChina Star0check-ins
- ClosedChinatown0check-ins
- ClosedChinatown Restaurant0check-ins
- ClosedChipotle Mexican Grill0check-ins
- ClosedColandrea Pizza King0check-ins
- ClosedCorner Deli0check-ins
- ClosedCosimo's Brick Oven0check-ins
- ClosedCrown Fried Chicken0check-ins
- ClosedCuginos0check-ins
- ClosedDairy Queen0check-ins
- ClosedDenny's0check-ins
- ClosedDeStefano's Olde Erie Pub & Grill0check-ins
- ClosedDinatellos Pizza0check-ins
- ClosedDolson Avenue Pizzeria and Deli0check-ins
- ClosedDomino's Pizza0check-ins